A side-by-side used-car reliability comparison built from NHTSA recall data, owner complaints, safety ratings, and curated known issues.
CarScorer take
Based on public data, the 2019 BMW X5 scores higher (5.7 vs 4.3) — largely on fewer recalls and complaint history.
Reliability score is a model-level estimate from public NHTSA data and known-issue severity — not a per-listing deal score. Score a specific VIN for a full breakdown.
Looking at a specific listing?
Enter a VIN, mileage, and asking price for a personalised score with market comparison — free.
Use your CarScorer analysis to negotiate with confidence. Open each listing site in a new tab to compare active inventory.
Accessories & exterior protection
Shop accessories & exterior protectionFloor mats, running boards, fender flares, tonneau covers & more
Suspension & performance
Wheel spacers, leveling & lift kits, suspensionKSP Performance — 5% off site-wide with code KSPAF
Need a rental while you shop?
Browse rental cars from $9/dayCarScorer may earn a commission from these links, at no cost to you.
Use your CarScorer analysis to negotiate with confidence. Open each listing site in a new tab to compare active inventory.
Accessories & exterior protection
Shop accessories & exterior protectionFloor mats, running boards, fender flares, tonneau covers & more
Suspension & performance
Wheel spacers, leveling & lift kits, suspensionKSP Performance — 5% off site-wide with code KSPAF
Need a rental while you shop?
Browse rental cars from $9/dayCarScorer may earn a commission from these links, at no cost to you.